"My favorite non-dairy milk to use is coconut cream because ... if you do get a can with a pronounced coconut taste, it will work best with other tropical and fruity flavors.
While nothing will taste exactly like dairy milk, (because of its protein ... Bernat Bacete/Getty Images Even if you narrow down the best non-dairy option for baking to either soy milk or almond ...
However, a relatively neutral-tasting option like unflavored soy milk or pea milk is best for replicating dairy milk. Be mindful of baking with strongly flavored alternatives like coconut ...